Some titles that come to my mind, that I seem to never tire of watching . . . (these are the non-JW titles) -
Return to Me
While You Were Sleeping
Beauty and the Beast (Disney)
Mulan
The Parent Trap (both)
Everafter
Space Cowboys
1776
The Ultimate Gift
Veggie Tales
The Bachelor & the Bobby Soxer
North by Northwest
An Affair to Remember
People Will Talk
Shop Around the Corner
The Adventures of Robin Hood (w/ Errol Flynn)
The Prince & the Pauper (also w/ Errol Flynn)
Mrs. C 
Lt. B,
All is forgiven! How strange that the info on the box is incorrect! Why would you even think to 'investigate' further? I would have done the same as you . . . believed the box 
.
Either way, Shirley Temple or Anne Sheridan, it sounds like it was a good movie, that you enjoyed! We'll have to check it out sometime!
Mrs. C
The others are one's that I remembered as being good but watching them again, they were not so good.
Yeah, I remember my reaction after re-watching Clint's three spaghetti westerns and the first 3-4 James Bond movies after twenty-five years.
My bubble was popped.
Chester 
Speaking of Miss Temple, I thought she was just precious in Wagon Wheels with Randolph Scott.
Lt. B, you really had us going, because we thought there was a Shirley Temple movie we hadn't seen, and with Randolph Scott, to boot! But alas, t'was not to be . . . I think the adorable young thing in Wagon Wheels must have been Anne Sheridan, because Shirley wasn't listed in the cast (at least not on IMDb). She was with Randolph Scott in Rebecca of Sunnybrook Farm and Susannah of the Mounties.
Now to get back on topic . . . some movies that I could watch over and over and over again . . . and have (!) . . .
Return to Me
While You Were Sleeping
The Bachelor and the Bobby Soxer
It Takes Two
The Parent Trap (1996, especially)
Ever After
The Sons of Katie Elder
Tall in the Saddle
Mrs. C
Since we have several young'ens, we purchased the whole set of Shirley Temple colorized movies on VHS tapes (roughly 18 ) close to twenty years ago. All have been watched at least 10 times, some many more. Some have been upgraded to DVD. I highly recommend them, whether you have young'ens or not.
Chester
We've watched a lot of Duke movies many times over the years, but not every one we own - too many to list, in any case (it would be easier to list the ones we haven't watched over and over).
Christmas movies - definitely!
Back to the Future (all three)
Indiana Jones (all three original ones)
some Roy Rogers movies
Three Stooges
Chester and the Mrs. (you can tell which ones we watch by the smileys above)
(to be continued in future posts . . . )
