Hey Hondo,
They're two completely different movies. Same plot based on the same short story, but two completly different takes on that plot. Both are good, but I like the new one a little more...it's more of an action movie. The old one is more of a psycholgical western, "High Noon" style, with lots of talk, but it's good.
Since they're so different, one doesn't take anything away from the other. Hope that made sense.
