Bob,
Your list is a good one. I only have one name I'd like to add to it (but it's a big one). Remember, in 1960 Gary Cooper was still around. I don't think that any "ideal Western cast" would be complete without him. Someday (when I have more time) I will type up a longer post about Cooper and his contributions to the Western genre. But, I definitely would have Wayne and Cooper as the stars of my "Perfect Western."
